← Back to Unit 4

Unit 4, Lesson 5: Building Alternatives

Designing a Fairer Future

Duration: 60 minutes | Year Level: 4-6 | Subject: Social Sciences, Economics, Civics

Enrichment Suggestion (LF_SocialSciences): Introduce the concept of "The Commons" (Nga Taonga Tuku Iho). Things that belong to everyone and shouldn't be sold (e.g., air, water, language, open-source software).

Learning Objectives (Whāinga Ako)

Students will understand:

  • There are alternatives to the standard "profit-first" business model.
  • How Cooperatives distribute wealth differently to Corporations.
  • The idea of an "Ecological Ceiling" and "Social Foundation" (The Doughnut).

Students will be able to:

  • Design a basic set of rules for a new economic system.
  • Critique current systems using the "Fairness" lens.
  • Explain why "Growth at all costs" might be a problem on a finite planet.

Lesson Structure

Do Now: The Island Rulebook (10 minutes)

Scenario

The class is shipwrecked on a desert island. It is rich in fruit, fish, and timber. You need to decide how to run things before chaos breaks out.

  • Choice A: One person owns the island. Everyone else works for them to earn food.
  • Choice B: Everyone owns the island together. Work and food are shared equally.
  • Choice C: People own what they can fence off. If you're slow, you get the bad land.

Vote: Which system do you choose and why?

Activity 1: The Cooperative Difference (15 minutes)

The Corporation

  • Goal: Maximize profit for shareholders (who might not even work there).
  • Decisions: Made by the people with the most money/shares.
  • Example: A typical supermarket chain.

The Cooperative (Co-op)

  • Goal: Serve the members (workers or customers).
  • Decisions: One member, one vote (Democracy).
  • Example: Fonterra (Farmer owned), Foodstuffs (Store owned).
  • Key Idea: Wealth stays with the people who do the work.

Activity 2: Doughnut Economics (15 minutes)

Visualizing Balance

Imagine a Doughnut. In the hole is poverty (not enough food, housing). Outside the ring is pollution (climate change). We want to live IN the Doughnut.

The Social Foundation (Inner Ring)

No one falls below this. Everyone has:

  • Food & Water
  • Healthcare
  • Education
  • Voice

The Ecological Ceiling (Outer Ring)

We don't overshoot this using:

  • Too much carbon
  • Too much freshwater
  • Too much land

Capstone Activity: Design Your Own Economy (20 minutes)

The Challenge

In groups, design a new economic system for Aotearoa in 2050.

You must decide:

  1. Who owns the water? (Private companies, Government, Nobody/Everyone?)
  2. How do businesses make decisions? (Bosses decide vs Workers vote)
  3. What counts as "Success"? (GDP/Money vs Well-being/Happiness)
  4. How do you look after Papatūānuku?

Wrap-up & Reflection (5 minutes)

Exit Ticket Questions:

  1. What is one advantage of a Cooperative business?
  2. Why can't we just keep "growing" the economy forever? (Think about the Doughnut).
  3. What is one hope you have for the future economy of Aotearoa?

Unit Complete!

You have explored systems, wealth, history, and future alternatives. You are now Economic Justice experts.

🎬 Media Anchor

Use this clip to model how communities organize practical alternatives when existing systems are inequitable.

Video anchor: Collective strategies for fairer futures

  • Pause and discuss: Which action in the clip is most transferable to our class design-for-change proposals?
  • Transfer task: Students add one evidence point from the clip to their written analysis before continuing.

Resources & Homework

Required Resources:

  • Paper and colors for "Doughnut" drawing
  • Co-op vs Corp comparison chart

Homework/Extension:

  • Investigate: Find a business in your town that is a Cooperative or Social Enterprise.
  • Watch: "Kate Raworth: Doughnut Economics" (TED Talk) - for advanced students.

📋 Teacher Planning Snapshot

Ngā Whāinga Ako — Learning Intentions

Students will engage with this resource to critically examine economic systems — understanding how wealth, power, and resources are distributed in Aotearoa New Zealand, and exploring indigenous and alternative economic frameworks that prioritise collective wellbeing, mana, and tino rangatiratanga over individual accumulation.

Ngā Paearu Angitū — Success Criteria

  • ✅ Students can explain how economic inequality is produced and sustained through systems, not just individual choices.
  • ✅ Students can describe at least one alternative economic model — including a Māori or indigenous framework — that challenges dominant assumptions about wealth and justice.

Differentiation & Inclusion

Scaffold support: Provide structured comparison frameworks (e.g., two-column tables: "current system vs alternative") for entry-level access. Offer extension tasks asking students to research a specific Māori economic enterprise (e.g., Ngāi Tahu Holdings, Tainui Group Holdings) and evaluate how it balances commercial success with cultural values.

ELL / ESOL: Economic concepts (equity, redistribution, exploitation, surplus value, collective ownership) need concrete grounding — use local NZ examples and visual infographics. Allow oral discussion of economic justice issues before written analysis. Draw connections to students' home countries' economic systems as valid comparative frameworks.

Inclusion: Economic discussions can touch on students' lived experiences of poverty, precarity, or privilege — create a safe, non-judgmental space. Neurodiverse learners benefit from concrete case studies rather than abstract theory. Frame economic justice as a systems problem, not a personal failing — this reframe is both accurate and inclusive.

Mātauranga Māori lens: The Māori economy before colonisation was not "primitive" — it was a sophisticated system of reciprocal exchange (utu), collective resource management (rāhui, kaitiakitanga), redistribution through manaakitanga, and wealth measured in relationships and obligations rather than individual accumulation. Colonisation deliberately disrupted these systems through land confiscation and the introduction of individual title. Contemporary Māori economic development — through iwi corporations, Māori land trusts, and social enterprises — represents a reclamation of rangatiratanga in the economic sphere. The concept of ōhanga Māori (Māori economy) offers a genuinely alternative framework for thinking about justice, sufficiency, and collective flourishing.

Prior knowledge: Students benefit from basic familiarity with how markets and governments work. No specialist economics knowledge required — the unit builds this progressively through accessible case studies.

Curriculum alignment

  • The Economic World — Social Studies: Understand how economic decisions affect people, communities, and environments, and how different groups seek to influence economic systems and outcomes.
  • Understand — Social Studies: Systems shape how people and groups organise themselves — including economic systems that distribute power, rights, and resources.

🌿 Nga Rauemi Tauwehe - External Resources

High-quality resources from official New Zealand education sites to extend and enrich this learning content.

Doughnut Economics Action Lab

Tools and stories for applying Doughnut Economics in communities and classrooms.

Years: 7-13 100% Match

Cooperative Business NZ

Information about the cooperative business model in Aotearoa New Zealand.

Years: 9-13 90% Match Official NZ Resource