🧺 Te Kete Ako

Cultural Preservation Essays

Cultural Preservation Essays · Years 9–12

Year LevelYears 9–12
TypeStudent handout — classroom resource

Ngā Whāinga Akoranga · Learning Intentions

  • Read and interpret texts for meaning, purpose, and author intent
  • Identify and analyse language choices, text structure, and rhetorical techniques
  • Write clearly and purposefully for a specific audience using appropriate conventions
  • Evaluate the credibility and perspective of texts and sources

Paearu Angitu · Success Criteria

  • I can identify the author's purpose and explain how the text achieves it
  • I can point to specific language choices and explain their effect on the reader
  • My writing is clear, focused, and uses appropriate conventions for the form
  • I can evaluate a source's credibility with reference to specific textual evidence
✍️ English — Argument Writing 🌿 Cultural Preservation 🎓 Year 9–12 🇳🇿 NZC Level 5–7

Cultural Preservation — Argumentative Essay Writing

✨ He reo, he oranga — a language, a life
"Ahakoa he iti, he pounamu" — Although it is small, it is precious as greenstone.
(Every surviving cultural practice — a waiata, a carving technique, a word — is pounamu. The question is whether we know it.)

Cultural practices — languages, arts, ceremonies, ways of relating to land — do not survive on their own. They survive because communities make deliberate decisions to practise, transmit, and invest in them. The question "Should we preserve culture?" sounds simple, but underneath it lie complex debates about authenticity, identity, economics, and who has the right to decide. In this handout, you will read real data about the state of te reo Māori and Māori cultural practices, build a structured argument, and write a persuasive essay at NCEA Level 1–3 standard.

Part 1 — He Raraunga, He Pono: The Data on Cultural Survival

Before you argue, you need evidence. Here is the current picture of te reo Māori and Māori cultural practice in Aotearoa:

4%
Percentage of Māori who could speak te reo fluently in 1995 — down from nearly 100% in 1840. A language had come within one generation of extinction.
23%
Percentage of Māori who can now hold a conversation in te reo (2023 Stats NZ). The revitalisation is working — but it required $1 billion+ in funding since 1987.
29,000
Students enrolled in kura kaupapa Māori (Māori-medium schools) in 2024. Research shows these students outperform on wellbeing, language, and identity metrics.
7,000
Languages currently spoken on Earth. By 2100, linguists estimate 3,500–5,000 will be extinct — one language dies every 14 days.
$3.6B
Estimated annual economic value of Māori cultural tourism, arts, and creative industries in Aotearoa (MBIE 2022) — culture is also economy.
  1. What surprises you most about this data? Write 2–3 sentences explaining what it reveals about the relationship between language loss and deliberate action.
  2. Calculate: if the fluent-te-reo percentage grew from 4% (1995) to 23% (2023) in 28 years, what is the average annual percentage point increase? At this rate, what year might 50% of Māori be te reo conversational?
  3. The last statistic suggests culture has significant economic value. Does framing culture as "economically valuable" strengthen or weaken the case for preserving it? Explain your position.

Part 2 — He Poupou Kōrero: Building Your Argument with PEEL

Strong argumentative writing follows a clear structure. PEEL is one reliable framework:

P
Point: State your argument clearly in one sentence. This is your topic sentence — make your position unmistakable.
E
Evidence: Provide specific, credible evidence — statistics, research findings, expert opinion, real examples. Never claim without evidence.
E
Explain: Connect your evidence back to your point. Explain why the evidence supports your argument — don't assume the reader sees the connection.
L
Link: Conclude the paragraph by reinforcing your point, or bridging to the next argument. Don't just repeat — elevate.

Example PEEL paragraph — argument FOR cultural preservation:

[P] Cultural preservation is not merely sentimental — it is a public health intervention with measurable outcomes. [E] Research by Dr Mere Berryman (University of Waikato, 2019) found that Māori students in te reo immersion schooling reported 34% higher wellbeing scores and significantly stronger cultural identity than their peers in English-medium schools. [E] This matters because cultural identity is one of the strongest predictors of resilience, mental health, and academic performance in indigenous youth globally. [L] Far from being a luxury, preserving te reo Māori is one of the most cost-effective investments Aotearoa can make in its future workforce and social fabric.
  1. Write your own PEEL paragraph arguing FOR cultural preservation. Use at least one statistic from Part 1 as your evidence. Label each PEEL component in the margin.
  2. Now write a PEEL paragraph arguing AGAINST prioritising cultural preservation — perhaps arguing that resources should go to housing, health, or poverty reduction instead. Use specific evidence. (NOTE: You do not need to personally agree with the argument you write.)

Part 3 — He Wero: Counter-Argument and Full Essay

The strongest essays acknowledge the other side — and then dismantle it. A counter-argument paragraph follows this structure:

Concede: "It is true that / Some argue that / Critics point out that..."
Refute: "However / Nevertheless / While this is partly true, it ignores..."
Reinforce: Return to your position, now strengthened by having engaged with the challenge.

The possible essay topics (choose ONE):

🗣️ Topic A — "Te reo Māori should be compulsory in all NZ schools."

Consider: language rights, resource costs, evidence from Welsh/Hebrew revitalisations, learning outcomes data, tikanga, Treaty obligations.

🎭 Topic B — "Haka performed in commercial or competitive settings (sports, tourism) diminishes its cultural value."

Consider: authenticity vs. accessibility, cultural commodification, the role of consent, economic benefits to iwi, perspectives of tohunga whakairo.

🌿 Topic C — "Governments have a moral obligation to fund cultural preservation, even at the expense of other spending."

Consider: Treaty obligations, opportunity cost, comparative international examples (Ireland te Gaeilge, Wales Cymraeg), corporate vs. government responsibility.

  1. Essay planning: Complete the following plan before writing.
    • My chosen topic:
    • My position (thesis statement):
    • Argument 1 (+ evidence):
    • Argument 2 (+ evidence):
    • Counter-argument + refutation:
    • Conclusion / call to action:
  2. Full essay (450–600 words): Introduction (thesis + preview), two body paragraphs (PEEL), one counter-argument paragraph (concede → refute → reinforce), and a conclusion. Write on a separate page or below.

✨ Whakamutunga — He kōrero tuku iho

Culture is not a museum exhibit. It is a living conversation between ancestors and descendants — a conversation that can be interrupted, nearly broken, and then, with extraordinary effort, resumed. Te reo Māori came within a generation of silence. It did not go silent, because people chose to fight. Your essay is one small part of that conversation. Make it count.

Te wero: Find and listen to a waiata or kōrero in te reo Māori that moves you. Write 100 words describing what it communicates — and what would be lost if no one could understand it anymore.

🌿 Ngā Rauemi Hono — Related Resources

Hononga Marautanga · Curriculum Alignment

English — Te Reo Pākehā

Level 3–4: Read and interpret a range of texts for meaning and purpose; identify author intent, text structure, and language choices; write clearly for specific audiences and purposes using appropriate conventions.

Social Sciences — Tikanga ā-Iwi

Level 3–4: Understand how texts construct knowledge and perspective; evaluate the credibility and purpose of different sources; communicate ideas and findings effectively in written and oral forms.

Tuhia ōu whakaaro · Write Your Thoughts

Reflect on your learning. What was the most important idea? What question do you still have?

Aronga Mātauranga Māori

In te ao Māori, language — reo — is a taonga: a treasure that carries culture, identity, and whakapapa across generations. The ability to speak clearly, to argue persuasively, to read critically, and to write with purpose are not simply academic skills — they are forms of mana in action. Māori oratory (whaikōrero) has always valued precision, evidence, and the ability to locate one's argument within a broader cultural and ancestral context. Students who develop strong literacy skills are developing the same capacities that made great orators powerful: the ability to be heard, understood, and taken seriously in any room they enter.

Ngā Rauemi Tautoko · Resources already provided

This handout is designed to be used alongside other resources in the same unit. Related materials are linked in the unit planner. All content is provided — no additional preparation is required to use this handout in your classroom.

📋 Teacher Planning Snapshot

Ngā Whāinga Ako — Learning Intentions

Students will engage with this resource to build core literacy skills — reading comprehension, writing craft, and oral language — grounded in the rich storytelling traditions of Aotearoa New Zealand and the literacy practices that empower rangatahi voice.

Ngā Paearu Angitū — Success Criteria

  • ✅ Students can apply the literacy skill or strategy featured in this resource with growing independence.
  • ✅ Students can connect this resource's literacy focus to authentic texts, contexts, or purposes from their own world.

Differentiation & Inclusion

Scaffold support: Provide sentence starters, word banks, or graphic organisers for entry-level access. Model think-alouds before independent tasks. Offer extension challenges that deepen analysis — for example, comparing the author's craft choices across two texts or writing an additional stanza or paragraph.

ELL / ESOL: Pre-teach key vocabulary before reading. Allow students to annotate in their home language first, then translate key ideas. Use shared reading and think-pair-share structures to lower the stakes for language production. Bilingual glossaries and visual text supports help bridge comprehension.

Inclusion: Chunk reading and writing tasks into manageable steps. Offer multimodal options — oral, visual, or digital — for students to demonstrate understanding. Neurodiverse learners benefit from clear task structures and explicit success criteria. Affirm diverse linguistic and cultural backgrounds as assets, not deficits.

Mātauranga Māori lens: Literacy in Te Ao Māori encompasses tātai kōrero (the arrangement of speech), waiata, whakataukī, and the deep art of kōrero — storytelling as knowledge transmission. Encourage students to see their own family stories and community knowledge as valid literacy texts. Karakia opens and closes learning with intention. Tātai kōrero honours the voice.

Prior knowledge: Adaptable across year levels. No specialist prior knowledge required for entry-level engagement. Teachers may wish to pre-read the resource and anticipate vocabulary that needs pre-teaching.

Curriculum alignment